<\/p>\n
Bukit Brown, Development and Possibilities for Singapore <\/strong><\/em><\/p>\n By Ian Chong<\/strong><\/em><\/p>\n Recent events and public discussions about public transport, the environment, and heritage should give pause to the proposed construction of the dual four-lane carriageway across Bukit Brown. Singaporeans have one last opportunity to consider the consequences of irrevocably altering the face of an important part of our nation\u2019s natural and cultural landscape before the planned exhumations begin in October 2013. Surveys for Our Singapore Conversation indicate that 62 percent of Singaporeans prefer preserving green spaces over constructing roads and other infrastructure, while 53 percent prefer heritage preservation over infrastructure building. (OSC Survey, p. 6) Staying road construction over Bukit Brown demonstrates responsiveness to public needs.<\/p>\n Simply building roads, such as one over Bukit Brown, does not address the fundamental reason underlying congestion in Singapore. As Kishore Mahbubani, dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, pointed out, the fundamental challenge facing road space in Singapore is sub-optimal public transport, which heightens demand for car use. (ST, Sep 14) Recent steps by the LTA to raise ERP rates and introduce new considerations for the COE underscore the fact that controlling vehicle population should be key to addressing the traffic snarling our roads. The heavy traffic on Lornie Road during rush hours comes from vehicles filtering on and off a congested PIE, an issue a road through Bukit Brown is unlikely to solve. In fact, Singapore can probably never build enough roads if current approaches to car use and public transport are not thoroughly re-thought.<\/p>\n In fact, the Prime Minister\u2019s National Day Rally statement about being able to maintain possibilities for Singapore stands in stark contrast to National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan\u2019s claim that it is necessary to sacrifice Bukit Brown and nature for construction. (Zaobao, Sept. 28) Today\u2019s Singapore is no longer in the 1960s where infrastructure development was imperative.<\/p>\n The haste to construct the dual four-lane carriageway – and other follow-on developments – over Bukit Brown may even be counter-productive. Flooding earlier this month serves as a reminder of the need for development projects to proceed with caution. As the NEA subsequently stated, \u201cRapid development and urbanisation…are likely to be significant factors which may explain this trend [of heavy precipitation leading to flooding].\u201d (Today, Sept 13) The Expert Panel on Drainage Design and Flood Prevention Measures likewise noted, \u201cincreased urbanisation in the Stamford Canal Catchment might have been a contributing factor to the 2010 and 2011 floods…\u201d (p. 13)<\/p>\n Moreover, the panel observed that \u201cother than generating higher and faster surface run-off, increased urbanization may also bring about other impacts such as increased heat production, changes in rainfall patterns and other climate change impacts…\u201d (p. 13) Panel recommendations to mitigate the effects of urbanisation is recognition of the relationship between rapid, large-scale development and flooding. (p.1, 9, 15, 52, 55) Notably, the Environmental Impact Assessment for the road across Bukit Brown remains unavailable for public access.<\/p>\n Building the road over Bukit Brown may prove to be a temporary patch rather a real solution to the challenges of congestion, and can potentially create more difficulties down the line. The LTA and URA should hold off construction until there are more comprehensive ad appropriate ways to address the environmental, heritage, traffic, and development issues that intersect at Bukit Brown.<\/p>\nPrime Minister Lee Hsien Loong\u2019s last National Day Rally should provide more impetus for maintaining Bukit Brown in its current form. According to Mr. Lee, new plans to develop Singapore\u2019s southern and eastern coasts along with Paya Lebar mean that, \u201cwe do not have to worry about running out of space or possibilities for Singapore. We are not at the limit, the sky is the limit! We are creating possibilities for the future.\u201d This means that there is space for Bukit Brown in its current form in our future and those of our children.<\/em><\/strong><\/span><\/h2>\n
As physical changes in Singapore become ever more prevalent, the remaining tangible markers of our unique heritage and history only grow in importance to society. This is a reality that digitisation can never fully replace or replicate.<\/strong><\/em><\/span><\/h2>\n
At a minimum, there ought to be a rigorous, publicly available study first. This is a first step toward finding a more comprehensive and sustainable approach to the issues above.\u00a0\u00a0Halting construction clearly comes with costs, but these may be much lower that those from building the road. Singapore is worth the extra effort.<\/strong><\/em><\/span><\/h2>\n